Rights and warrants are both securities that give the holder the right to buy stock at a specific price. They're related but different instruments, and the Series 7 tests you on the distinctions.
---
When a company wants to raise more capital by issuing new shares, it risks diluting existing shareholders — suddenly their ownership percentage shrinks because there are more shares outstanding.
To protect shareholders, companies issue subscription rights — short-term securities that let existing shareholders buy the new shares before the public, at a discount to the current market price.
Scenario: ABC Corp trades at $50/share. The company needs to raise capital and will issue 1 million new shares at $45 (a $5 discount). Existing shareholders receive rights to buy new shares at $45.
The exam may ask you to calculate a right's value:
When stock is trading "rights-on" (before ex-rights date): > Value = (Market Price − Subscription Price) ÷ (Rights Required + 1)
When stock is trading "ex-rights" (after ex-rights date): > Value = (Market Price − Subscription Price) ÷ Rights Required
Example: Stock trades at $55. Subscription price is $50. 4 rights needed to buy 1 share.
1. Exercise: Use the rights + pay the subscription price to buy new shares 2. Sell: Rights trade on the market; sell them for their market value 3. Let them expire: Lose any value — generally a bad choice if rights have value
The investment bank agrees to buy any unsold shares from the rights offering (the "standby"). This ensures the company raises its full intended capital even if some shareholders don't exercise their rights.
---
Warrants are also the right to buy stock at a fixed price — but they're very different from rights:
| Feature | Rights | Warrants | |---------|--------|---------| | Duration | Short-term (30–45 days) | Long-term (years, sometimes perpetual) | | Who gets them | Existing shareholders (protection tool) | New investors (sweetener to sell bonds/preferred) | | Price | Below current market (discount) | Above current market (premium) | | Purpose | Prevent dilution of existing holders | Entice investors to buy bonds or preferred stock |
Warrants are typically attached to bonds or preferred stock as a "sweetener" — they make the bond or preferred more attractive. If the stock price rises above the warrant's exercise price, investors profit.
Example: A company issues bonds with warrants attached. Each bond includes a warrant to buy 100 shares of stock at $30. The stock currently trades at $25. The warrant is currently "out of the money" — there's no immediate profit.
If the stock later rises to $45, the warrant is now worth exercising: buy 100 shares at $30 × 100 = $3,000, worth $45 × 100 = $4,500. $1,500 profit per warrant exercised.
---
The exam loves to test whether candidates can distinguish these two:
| | Rights | Warrants | |---|--------|---------| | Time horizon | Short (weeks) | Long (years) | | Issued to | Existing shareholders | New bond/preferred investors | | Exercise price | Below market (discount) | Above market (premium) | | Primary purpose | Anti-dilution protection | Investment sweetener |
---
---
Quiz Questions:
Q1. XYZ Corp stock trades at $60. The company issues subscription rights allowing shareholders to buy new shares at $55. It takes 5 rights to buy one new share. The stock is still trading rights-on. What is the theoretical value of one right?
A) $5.00 B) $1.00 C) $0.83 D) $1.25
Answer: C — Rights-on formula: (Market − Subscription) ÷ (Rights Required + 1) = ($60 − $55) ÷ (5 + 1) = $5 ÷ 6 = $0.83. The "+1" accounts for the fact that the stock price still includes the value of the right that hasn't separated yet.
---
Q2. A shareholder receives rights in a subscription offering. She neither exercises nor sells her rights and lets them expire. What is the economic impact?
A) No impact — she still owns the same number of shares B) She experiences dilution — her ownership percentage shrinks as new shares are issued to others C) She earns the subscription price as income D) She receives additional shares automatically
Answer: B — By not exercising OR selling her rights, she lets something valuable expire worthless. Meanwhile, others buy the new shares at a discount. Her percentage ownership shrinks (dilution), and the stock price typically adjusts downward. Rights have value — discarding them is an economic loss.
---
Q3. A company issues bonds with attached warrants to buy common stock at $40 per share. The stock currently trades at $35. A year later the stock trades at $50. Which statement is correct?
A) The warrant is worthless because it was issued when the stock was below the exercise price B) The warrant is now in the money; exercising at $40 and selling at $50 generates a $10 profit per share C) Warrants are only exercisable at issuance; they cannot be used after one year D) The investor must own the bond to exercise the warrant
Answer: B — The warrant allows purchase at $40; the stock is now worth $50. Exercising generates $10 profit per share covered by the warrant. Warrants can be detached from bonds and trade separately; they don't expire merely because time passes (they have multi-year terms). They're in the money when market price > exercise price.
---
Q4. Which of the following most accurately describes a key difference between subscription rights and warrants?
A) Rights are issued to new investors; warrants protect existing shareholders B) Rights have a short life (weeks); warrants are long-term (years) C) Rights are exercisable at a premium to market price; warrants at a discount D) Warrants are only issued during rights offerings
Answer: B — Rights: short-term (30–45 days), existing shareholders, discount to market. Warrants: long-term (years), new investors who buy bonds/preferred, premium to current market. Option A reverses the two; option C reverses the pricing. Option D is false — warrants are attached to new bond/preferred issuances.
---
Q5. When a company conducts a rights offering, what role does a standby underwriter play?
A) The standby underwriter sets the subscription price for the rights B) The standby underwriter agrees to purchase any shares not subscribed to by existing shareholders C) The standby underwriter manages the secondary market trading of the rights D) The standby underwriter lends shares to shareholders who want to exercise their rights
Answer: B — A standby underwriter provides a backstop guarantee: if some shareholders don't exercise their rights, the standby buys the leftover shares, ensuring the company raises its full target amount. This is common for large rights offerings where the company can't afford for the offering to fail due to low participation.