Estimated study time: 60 minutes
Content:
The Asset Manager Code (AMC) is a voluntary set of ethical principles established by CFA Institute specifically for firms that manage assets on behalf of clients. While the Standards of Professional Conduct apply to individual CFA members, the AMC is a firm-level code designed to govern the entire organization's conduct. At CFA Level 2, candidates must understand the six components of the AMC, how they translate into specific firm-level policies, and how to apply them to vignette scenarios involving asset management firms rather than individual advisers. A firm that claims compliance with the AMC must comply with all provisions — partial compliance claims are not permitted.
The six components of the Asset Manager Code are: (1) Loyalty to Clients — placing client interests above the firm's and acting as a fiduciary; (2) Investment Process and Risk — using sound and documented investment processes and risk management; (3) Trading — seeking best execution and not disadvantaging clients through trading practices; (4) Risk Management, Compliance, and Support — maintaining robust compliance infrastructure; (5) Performance and Valuation — presenting performance fairly and valuing client portfolios accurately; and (6) Disclosures — providing clients with timely, accurate, and complete information about the firm, its services, fees, conflicts of interest, and risk. Vignette questions may describe a firm's policies and ask whether the firm is in compliance with the AMC.
The Loyalty to Clients component at the firm level encompasses acting as a fiduciary in all client relationships, not suborning the firm's interests to client interests through fee structures or product selection, and having policies that govern personal trading by all staff (not just CFA charterholders). A common AMC testing scenario involves soft dollar arrangements, where a firm directs client brokerage to brokers who provide research or other services. Soft dollar practices are permissible under the AMC only when (a) the research directly benefits clients whose brokerage generated it, (b) the arrangement is disclosed to clients, and (c) the firm seeks best execution. Using client brokerage to purchase services that primarily benefit the firm (e.g., software used for back-office administration, office furniture, entertainment) violates the AMC.
Performance and Valuation under the AMC requires that firms value client assets using objective, fair, and verifiable methods. Firms must not inflate valuations to increase management fees, misrepresent performance by selectively reporting favorable periods, or use misleading benchmarks. While GIPS is a separate voluntary standard, the AMC requires fair performance presentation consistent with GIPS principles. At Level 2, vignettes may describe a firm that cherry-picks inception dates, excludes terminated accounts from composites, or uses a benchmark that does not accurately reflect the strategy's risk and return profile. Each of these practices violates the AMC's performance component even absent a specific GIPS framework claim.
Disclosures under the AMC are extensive and ongoing. The firm must provide clients with quarterly performance reports (with appropriate benchmarks), annual financial statements, descriptions of all fees and compensation, disclosures of conflicts of interest (including affiliated broker relationships, principal trades, and revenue-sharing arrangements), proxy voting policies, and information about the firm's regulatory history. The AMC requires that clients receive sufficient information to evaluate whether the firm is acting in their best interests. A critical distinction at Level 2 is between required disclosures (regulatory minimums) and AMC-level disclosure (which is more comprehensive). A firm may satisfy regulators but still violate the AMC if its disclosures are technically accurate but presented in a way that obscures relevant information from clients.
Key Terms:
Quiz Questions:
Q1. Meridian Asset Management claims full compliance with the CFA Institute Asset Manager Code. A review of its practices reveals that Meridian directs 30% of client brokerage commissions to a brokerage that provides Meridian with equity research. This research is used exclusively to manage the same client accounts that generated the commissions, and the arrangement is disclosed to those clients. Meridian also uses 5% of client commissions to pay for Bloomberg terminal subscriptions used by Meridian's fixed income trading desk, which does not manage the accounts that generated the commissions. Which of the following best describes Meridian's compliance with the AMC?
A) Meridian is fully compliant because the total soft dollar usage is less than 35% of commissions. B) Meridian is partially compliant — the equity research soft dollar arrangement is permissible, but using commissions to pay for Bloomberg terminals violates the AMC. C) Meridian is non-compliant because all soft dollar arrangements are prohibited under the AMC. D) Meridian is compliant because Bloomberg terminals provide research benefit and are an acceptable soft dollar use.
Answer: B — The AMC permits soft dollar arrangements when the research directly benefits the clients whose brokerage generated it. Directing client brokerage to receive equity research used for those same accounts is permissible and is disclosed. However, using commissions to pay for Bloomberg terminals for a different desk (fixed income) that does not serve the accounts generating the brokerage creates a benefit to the firm, not those specific clients. This is a misuse of client brokerage and violates the AMC's loyalty and trading components.
---
Q2. A portfolio manager at a firm that claims AMC compliance is preparing the quarterly performance report. She excludes from the report three accounts that were terminated during the quarter because they underperformed and she believes "terminated accounts are no longer relevant to current clients." The remaining accounts show a composite return of 8.2% for the quarter. Which AMC component is most directly violated?
A) Investment Process and Risk. B) Trading — Best Execution. C) Performance and Valuation. D) Disclosures — Conflicts of Interest.
Answer: C — The Performance and Valuation component of the AMC requires that firms present performance in a fair and complete manner. Excluding terminated accounts that underperformed creates a survivorship bias that misleads current clients about the strategy's actual results. This is a classic form of performance misrepresentation. All accounts managed per the strategy — including terminated ones — should be included in the composite for the periods they were managed.
---
Q3. Fortress Capital manages pension assets for corporate clients. Fortress also runs an affiliated broker-dealer, Fortress Securities. Fortress Capital routinely routes client trades through Fortress Securities without disclosing the affiliated relationship to clients and without comparing execution quality to other brokers. Which AMC components are most likely violated?
A) Loyalty to Clients and Disclosures. B) Investment Process and Risk only. C) Risk Management, Compliance, and Support only. D) Trading only.
Answer: A — The affiliated broker relationship is a material conflict of interest that must be disclosed to clients under the Disclosures component. Additionally, the failure to seek or compare execution quality means the firm may not be achieving best execution — violating the Loyalty to Clients component (acting in clients' best interests) and the Trading component. In practice, all three components are violated, but A best captures the primary issues.
---
Q4. A client of Apex Asset Management asks Apex to buy 50,000 shares of a small-cap stock. Apex's trading desk happens to hold 50,000 shares of that same stock in its proprietary inventory. Apex executes the trade by selling from its inventory to the client at a price slightly above the prevailing market ask. Under the AMC, which of the following must Apex do?
A) Refuse to execute principal transactions under any circumstances. B) Disclose the principal nature of the transaction and obtain client consent before executing. C) Execute the trade at the prevailing ask price without any additional disclosure obligations. D) Report the transaction to regulators but no client disclosure is required.
Answer: B — A principal transaction occurs when the firm acts as counterparty to a client trade using its own inventory. The AMC requires firms to disclose the principal nature of such transactions and obtain client consent. This is because the firm has a direct financial interest in the trade (buying low / selling high from inventory), creating an inherent conflict with the client's interest in getting the best price.
---
Q5. Which of the following practices at an AMC-claiming firm would NOT constitute a violation of the Asset Manager Code?
A) A manager votes client proxies in favor of management proposals across all holdings to avoid conflict with corporate clients, without independent analysis. B) A manager directs all trading to the broker offering the lowest commission rate, without considering execution quality or market impact. C) A manager provides clients with a detailed annual disclosure listing all fees, compensation arrangements, and conflicts of interest. D) A manager values illiquid private equity holdings using a methodology that has not been updated since inception despite changed market conditions.
Answer: C — Providing a detailed, accurate annual disclosure of fees, compensation, and conflicts is exactly what the AMC's Disclosures component requires — this is compliant behavior. Option A violates the proxy voting policy requirement (voting must be in client interests through independent analysis). Option B may violate best execution by focusing solely on commissions and ignoring execution quality and market impact. Option D violates the Performance and Valuation component by using outdated and potentially inaccurate valuation methods.
---