Estimated study time: 45 minutes
Content:
The Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS) are a set of ethical principles for investment firms covering how they calculate and present investment performance to prospective clients. Created and administered by CFA Institute, GIPS provide a globally consistent, standardized framework that allows investors to compare performance across firms and geographies on an apples-to-apples basis. GIPS are voluntary — firms are not legally required to claim compliance — but once a firm claims GIPS compliance, it must apply the standards to all of its composites and follow all applicable requirements. As of 2020, the GIPS standards were significantly revised to cover asset owners (e.g., pension funds) and to expand guidance for alternatives, overlay strategies, and pooled funds.
A cornerstone of GIPS is the concept of the composite. A composite is a grouping of all discretionary portfolios managed according to the same investment mandate, objective, or strategy. For example, a firm running a large-cap value equity strategy for multiple clients must include all discretionary large-cap value accounts in a single composite — it cannot cherry-pick its best-performing accounts to show prospective clients. This anti-cherry-picking requirement is the central protection GIPS provides to investors. Composites must include all fee-paying, discretionary accounts, and firms must define composite criteria in advance (not retroactively based on performance). Non-discretionary accounts — where clients restrict the manager's investment decisions — are excluded from composites.
GIPS imposes specific calculation and presentation requirements. Returns must be calculated using time-weighted rates of return (TWRR), which eliminate the distorting effect of client cash flows on performance measurement. For example, if a client deposits a large sum just before a market drop, a money-weighted return would be dragged down in a way that reflects the client's timing, not the manager's skill. TWRR neutralizes this by geometrically linking sub-period returns before and after external cash flows. Firms must present composite performance for a minimum of five years (or since inception if shorter), building toward a ten-year minimum track record. Annual composite returns must be presented along with a benchmark, the number of portfolios in the composite, composite assets as a percentage of total firm assets, and a measure of composite dispersion.
GIPS verification is an independent third-party review of a firm's performance calculation and composite construction processes to assess GIPS compliance. Verification is firm-wide — not composite-specific — and does not constitute an audit of individual composites. Firms may also obtain composite-level performance examinations. For the CFA Level 1 exam, candidates must understand the key definitions (composite, verification, discretionary), the mandatory calculation method (TWRR), what must be included in compliant presentations, and the rationale behind each requirement. GIPS is also closely related to Standard III(D) Performance Presentation under the Standards of Professional Conduct, which requires that performance be presented fairly and accurately.
Key Terms:
Quiz Questions:
Q1. An investment manager claims GIPS compliance for its large-cap equity strategy. When constructing the composite for this strategy, the manager should include:
A) All large-cap equity accounts that outperformed the benchmark during the period B) All fee-paying, discretionary large-cap equity accounts, regardless of performance C) Only accounts with assets above $1 million, to ensure the composite reflects institutional mandates D) Only accounts that have been managed for more than one full year
Answer: B — GIPS requires that composites include all fee-paying, discretionary portfolios managed according to the same strategy. Excluding accounts based on performance (Option A), size (Option C), or tenure (Option D) would constitute cherry-picking, which GIPS is specifically designed to prevent. All accounts meeting the composite definition must be included.
---
Q2. A firm calculates its composite performance using money-weighted returns. A prospective client asks whether the firm is GIPS-compliant. The firm states that it is. This claim is:
A) Accurate, because GIPS allows firms to choose between money-weighted and time-weighted returns B) Inaccurate, because GIPS requires time-weighted rates of return for most composites C) Accurate, because money-weighted returns better reflect manager skill D) Inaccurate, because GIPS prohibits firms from calculating returns internally
Answer: B — GIPS requires time-weighted rates of return for most composites because TWRR eliminates the distorting effect of client-controlled cash flows, allowing comparison of manager skill across accounts with different cash flow patterns. Money-weighted returns (IRR) are permitted under GIPS for private equity and real assets, where cash flows are manager-controlled.
---
Q3. A GIPS-compliant firm with a five-year composite track record is presenting performance to a prospective client. The firm must include which of the following in the compliant presentation?
A) Performance only for years in which the strategy outperformed its benchmark B) The minimum five-year annual composite returns, benchmark returns, and number of portfolios in the composite C) Returns net of all taxes owed by underlying investors D) The names and individual performance records of all portfolios in the composite
Answer: B — GIPS-compliant presentations must include at minimum: five years of annual composite returns (building toward ten), benchmark returns for the same period, the number of portfolios in the composite, composite assets as a percentage of firm assets, and a measure of dispersion. Option A is cherry-picking, Option C is not required (GIPS uses pre-tax returns by convention), and Option D would violate client confidentiality.
---
Q4. GIPS verification is BEST described as:
A) An audit of individual portfolio returns within a composite to confirm their accuracy B) A firm-wide review by an independent third party assessing whether the firm's processes comply with GIPS C) A CFA Institute certification that the firm's returns have been independently calculated D) A requirement for all firms claiming GIPS compliance to obtain annually
Answer: B — GIPS verification is a firm-wide (not composite-specific) independent review of a firm's performance calculation and composite construction procedures. It is not a formal audit of individual portfolios, not a CFA Institute certification, and — critically — verification is recommended but not required under GIPS. Firms can claim compliance without verification, though verification provides added credibility.
---
Q5. A portfolio manager includes a non-discretionary account in a GIPS composite because the account had strong returns that would improve the composite's track record. This action:
A) Is permissible if the account's returns are calculated using TWRR B) Is permissible if the client consents in writing C) Violates GIPS because non-discretionary accounts must be excluded from composites D) Is permissible for firms with fewer than 20 portfolios in the composite
Answer: C — GIPS explicitly requires that non-discretionary accounts be excluded from composites. Non-discretionary accounts are those where client-imposed restrictions prevent the manager from implementing the intended strategy fully. Including them, especially when they boost performance, is precisely the cherry-picking behavior GIPS is designed to prevent. Client consent and TWRR (Options A and B) are irrelevant to this determination.
---