A fiduciary is a person who holds a position of trust and must act in another's best interest. In California real estate, agents owe fiduciary duties to their principals — the highest standard of care recognized by law. California codifies these duties in Business and Professions Code Section 10176 and in the common law of agency. Failing to meet fiduciary duties can result in license suspension, lawsuits, civil damages, and in serious cases, criminal charges.
The six fiduciary duties owed to a principal are remembered with the acronym OLDCAR:
---
The agent must follow all lawful instructions from the principal promptly and completely. The key word is *lawful* — an agent is not required to follow instructions that are illegal, unethical, or that violate fair housing law.
Examples in California practice:
---
The agent must place the client's interests above all others — including the agent's own financial interest, the other party's interest, and the interests of third parties.
Violations of loyalty include:
California example: A buyer's agent in the South Bay knows a seller who is willing to sell off-market at below-market value. The agent buys the property herself, then flips it. Without disclosing her identity as the buyer and the profit opportunity to her client, this is a breach of loyalty and a BPC violation.
---
The agent must proactively disclose all material facts known to the agent that could affect the principal's decision. This goes beyond answering questions asked — the duty is affirmative. The agent must volunteer information.
Material fact: Any fact that would reasonably influence a buyer's decision to buy or a seller's decision to accept an offer or set a price.
In California, disclosure duties extend to non-clients as well — agents must disclose known material defects to buyers even when the agent represents the seller, because California law requires honesty and fair dealing toward all parties.
Examples:
Stigmatized properties: California Civil Code Section 1710.2 requires disclosure of a death on the property within the prior 3 years if the buyer asks. An agent does NOT need to volunteer death information unprompted if more than 3 years have passed. HIV/AIDS status of a prior occupant is never required to be disclosed under California law.
---
The agent must protect the client's confidential information from being disclosed to adverse parties. This duty survives the end of the listing or representation agreement.
What must remain confidential:
Confidentiality after the listing expires: If a seller's listing expires and the property is re-listed with a new broker, the former listing agent cannot share the seller's bottom line or motivation with the new agent or any buyer's agent. The duty of confidentiality continues indefinitely for information obtained during the representation.
Contrast with Disclosure: Confidentiality protects the client's strategic negotiating information. Disclosure requires sharing material facts about the property. These duties do not conflict — they address different types of information.
---
The agent (and broker) must account for all funds and property received on behalf of the client. In California, this means:
California DRE audit: The DRE conducts random trust account audits of brokerages. Brokers who fail to maintain proper trust fund accounting face license suspension or revocation.
---
The agent must use the skill, knowledge, and attention that a reasonably competent real estate professional would apply in the same situation. This includes:
Agent's visual inspection: California Civil Code Section 2079 requires all licensed agents representing a buyer or seller in a residential 1-4 unit sale to conduct a reasonably competent visual inspection of all accessible areas of the property and disclose any conditions that affect value or desirability. This applies to listing agents as well as buyer's agents.
---
While full fiduciary duties run only to the principal, California agents owe non-clients (the other party) a duty of:
These lesser duties to non-clients are sometimes called "statutory duties" as opposed to full fiduciary duties.
---
---
Quiz Questions:
Q1. A listing agent in Walnut Creek receives a written offer from a buyer. The seller has previously told the agent verbally, "Don't bother showing me any offers under $900,000." The offer is for $875,000. What must the listing agent do?
A) Discard the offer per the seller's instruction, because verbal instructions are binding B) Present the offer, because California law requires all written offers to be presented unless the seller gives written instruction to the contrary C) Present the offer only if the buyer's agent requests a response within 72 hours D) The agent may use judgment and withhold the offer if it is clearly below market value
Answer: B — California requires listing agents to present all written offers promptly, unless the seller has given written instruction not to present offers below a certain price. A verbal instruction alone is insufficient. The agent should obtain written confirmation of the seller's instruction before withholding any offer.
---
Q2. A buyer's agent in San Diego learns during escrow that her buyer-client is under extreme financial pressure and must close within 30 days or face a personal financial crisis. The listing agent calls and asks, "Is your buyer flexible on closing?" Which OLDCAR duty controls how the agent responds?
A) Disclosure — the agent must tell the listing agent about the buyer's financial situation B) Obedience — the agent must follow the listing agent's request for information C) Confidentiality — the buyer's financial pressure and timeline motivation are confidential negotiating information D) Reasonable care — the agent should disclose the timeline to facilitate a smooth transaction
Answer: C — The buyer's financial pressure and deadline are confidential negotiating information. Disclosing this to the listing agent would directly harm the buyer's negotiating position. The agent should give a neutral, non-committal answer about closing timeline flexibility.
---
Q3. A buyer's agent does a walkthrough of a home in Pasadena she is showing a client. She notices staining on the ceiling that suggests a prior roof leak, but the seller's disclosure says "no known roof issues." What must the agent do?
A) Nothing — the seller completed the TDS and that is sufficient; the agent's inspection duty is limited to reading disclosures B) Disclose the observed staining to the buyer and recommend further investigation, because the visual inspection duty requires her to report conditions she observes C) Report the staining only to the seller's agent and let them handle the disclosure D) Refuse to show the property until the seller updates the TDS
Answer: B — California Civil Code Section 2079 requires all agents (buyer's and seller's) to perform a reasonably competent visual inspection of accessible areas and disclose anything observed that affects value or desirability. Ceiling staining suggesting a prior leak is a material observation. The buyer's agent must disclose this to her client and recommend a professional roof inspection.
---
Q4. A broker in Los Angeles collects a $50,000 earnest money deposit from a buyer on a Monday. Under California law, by when must the funds be deposited into the broker's trust account?
A) Immediately upon receipt — same business day B) Within 3 business days of receipt C) Within 5 calendar days of receipt D) Upon mutual acceptance of the purchase agreement
Answer: B — California law requires trust funds (including earnest money deposits) to be deposited into a licensed broker's trust account within 3 business days of receipt. Failure to timely deposit trust funds is a violation of the accounting duty and DRE regulations.
---
Q5. A listing agent sold a home for a seller two years ago. The listing has since expired and the seller relisted with a new broker. A buyer's agent now contacts the former listing agent asking what the seller's "real" bottom line was during the prior listing. What should the former listing agent do?
A) Share the information freely because the listing agreement has expired B) Share it only if the new listing agent also consents C) Decline to share — the duty of confidentiality survives the end of the listing agreement D) Share it because the information is now two years old and no longer strategically relevant
Answer: C — The duty of confidentiality does not expire when the listing agreement ends. A former agent who discloses a client's negotiating bottom line, even after the relationship ends, breaches the ongoing duty of confidentiality and could face liability and DRE disciplinary action.